Short answer: foil for detail, came for large flat panels
Copper foil suits small, curved, or three-dimensional pieces, such as lamps, suncatchers, and boxes. Lead came suits large, flat, or geometric panels, especially windows. Lead came is also the common choice for exterior windows, when it is set with putty or cement. Many beginners start with copper foil because it needs less space and fewer tools.
How copper foil works
In the copper foil method, each glass edge is wrapped in adhesive copper foil, then burnished down. The foil is fluxed and soldered along every seam. Because the foil is thin, the lines are fine and flexible, so you can build tight curves and 3D forms. The solder itself forms the joint, so each seam is a strength point. For the studio most associated with the method, see Louis Comfort Tiffany’s lamps, windows and Favrile glass.
How lead came works
In the lead came method, the glass fits into H-shaped or U-shaped channels of lead came. The came is pressed down with a fid so the channels grip the glass. The joints where the came meets are soldered together. The lines are bolder and more even than foil lines. Lead came needs less solder per piece, but it needs more setup and a finishing step with putty or cement. For how the method was used in early church windows, see medieval stained glass techniques.
Look and line
- Copper foil gives thinner, more flexible lines. It suits detail, small pieces, and organic shapes.
- Lead came gives even, graphic lines. It suits bold designs and geometric patterns.
- Solder is visible in both methods. In foil work, the solder covers the whole seam and can be patinated. In lead came work, solder shows at the joints.
Strength and weather
Lead came gives a rigid panel, which helps with large or heavy pieces. It can be set in putty or cement, which makes the panel weather-resistant. Lead came can stretch over time if the panel is not framed or supported, so large panels often need a frame.
Copper foil is lighter, which suits 3D forms. For larger panels, or panels that will face the weather, foil usually needs extra framing or a border. Some artists use foil on exterior glass that is protected, for example in double-glazed units or behind safety glass. Check with an experienced glass artist before you build an exterior panel from foil.
Workflow and time
- Copper foil. Each piece must be foiled, burnished, fluxed, and soldered. Foiling takes time, but fine detail becomes quicker with practice.
- Lead came. Setup takes longer. You need to cut and fit the came, pin the panel, solder the joints, and then putty the finished panel. Once you know the method, large, simple panels can go faster than foil work.
Solder and cleanup
Copper foil uses more solder, because both sides of every seam are soldered along their full length. Lead came uses less solder, because it is soldered only at the joints. Both methods need flux removed after soldering. Lead came also needs putty or cement cleaned up around the edges when it is finished.
Cost and tools
Both methods need glass cutting tools, a grinder, and a soldering iron. Copper foil needs foil, a burnisher, flux, and solder. Lead came needs came in the right widths, a fid, a way to cut came, and putty or cement. Lead came setup usually needs more workspace. Check current prices from your supplier, since costs vary by region and by material.
Project guide
- Suncatcher or ornament. Copper foil.
- Lampshade or 3D box. Copper foil.
- Interior window. Either method, depending on size. Lead came suits larger windows.
- Exterior window. Lead came, set with putty or cement.
- Large flat panel. Lead came, or copper foil with a border.
- First project. A small copper foil suncatcher with simple shapes. See easy stained glass suncatcher patterns for beginners.
Mixing methods
Some artists combine the two methods, for example by using copper foil for small, curved areas within a larger leaded panel. This takes more planning, and the two methods need to meet cleanly at the edges. Start with one method until you are comfortable with it.
For the tools each method needs, see stained glass tools and materials. For how to solder the seams, read how to solder stained glass. For design choices that suit each method, see stained glass design: creating patterns.