Short answer: theology, politics, and practical change
Stained glass was lost in the Reformation for several reasons, not one. Some reformers objected to images in churches, and in some places crowds smashed windows. Governments seized church property and closed monasteries. Many congregations also replaced painted windows with plain glass so that worship would be brighter. These causes overlapped, and the level of destruction varied widely from region to region.
Why reformers objected to images
Many Protestant reformers argued that images of saints and religious scenes encouraged the worship of the wrong things. They pointed to the biblical commandment against idolatry, and they objected to shrines, relics, and devotion to saints. Not all reformers agreed. Martin Luther, for example, accepted religious images that taught the Bible, and his views were more moderate than those of some later reformers.
Where iconoclasm was most severe
Iconoclasm, the deliberate destruction of religious images, was most intense in some areas.
- Zurich and other Swiss cities removed images from churches in the 1520s, under the reformer Huldrych Zwingli.
- The Netherlands saw the Beeldenstorm, or “iconoclastic fury,” in 1566, when crowds destroyed images in many churches.
- England saw destruction in several waves, including under Edward VI in the 1540s and 1550s, and again during the Civil War and Puritan period in the 1640s.
- Scotland had major image destruction around 1559 and 1560.
These are broad patterns, not a count of every church. Local records show that the scale varied from building to building.
Monastic closures and church property
In England, the dissolution of the monasteries between 1536 and 1541 closed religious houses and seized their property. Monastic churches were often stripped, and their windows were lost or removed. Similar confiscations happened in other countries. When a building lost its revenue or its purpose, its windows were often neglected or taken out.
Plain glass and changing worship
Some congregations replaced painted windows with plain glass. Clear glass let in more light, which suited a worship style focused on reading and preaching. In many places this was both a practical and an aesthetic choice, and it removed the painted imagery that had been central to earlier windows.
Not every Protestant church destroyed glass
Destruction was not universal. Many Lutheran churches in Germany and Scandinavia kept their windows, and some reformed churches kept glass with biblical scenes or heraldry. Some windows were taken down and stored, and some were moved to other buildings. That is one reason fragments survive in museums and in later windows.
The Catholic response
The Catholic Church responded with the Council of Trent, which met from 1545 to 1563 and affirmed the use of sacred images as teaching aids. Commissions for stained glass continued in Catholic areas, and windows remained part of many Catholic church programs. For the Renaissance painting that followed, see Renaissance stained glass art.
What was lost and what survived
Losses changed what remains today. Many medieval and Renaissance windows are known now only from fragments, drawings, or records. Surviving glass is spread across churches, museums, and private collections. When you visit an older church, look for mismatched glass, plain sections, and patched panels. These can show where the Reformation or later damage took place.
For the Gothic windows that were lost or changed, see Gothic stained glass. For the wider story, read the history of stained glass and glass painting.